Sea Level Rise and Coastal Flood Web Tools Comparison Matrix - California

Why Use This? This matrix was created to provide the planning and coastal management communities with an expandable chart to compare the functions and methods of publicly available sea level rise and coastal flood web tools. The information in each column is provided by the web tool owner. Specific questions about the tools can be addressed to the tool owner through the contact information provided in their matrix column. For more information or to suggest additional web tools, visit the national matrix page.

The following agencies/organizations contributed to the development of information contained in this California matrix: The Nature Conservancy, NOAA Coastal Services Center, Climate Central, University of California Berkeley Geospatial Innovation Center, California Energy Commission, Point Blue Conservation Science, Gulf of Farallones National Marine Sanctuary, U.S. Geological Survey, Coravai LLC.

Suggested Citation: The Sea Level Rise and Coastal Flood Web Tools Comparison Matrix. The Nature Conservancy, NOAA's Office for Coastal Management, Climate Central. URL, Date Access:

Select Matrix for Another Location:

EMBED Climate Central
Surging Seas
Risk Finder
NOAA's Office for
Coastal Management
Sea Level Rise and Coastal Flooding Impacts Viewer


The Nature
Conservancy
Coastal Resilience
Ventura



CA Energy Commission, CalEPA, CA MTC, CA DOT, and the CA OPC
Pacific Institute: The Impacts of Sea Level
Rise on California's Coast

California Energy Commission; UC-Berkeley Geospatial Innovation Facility
Cal-Adapt: Exploring California's Climate
Point Blue Conservation Science; USGS; Gulf of the Farallones National Marine Sanctuary; Coravai LCC
Our Coast, Our Future

Point Blue Conservation Science; USGS; USC Sea Grant, San Diego Regional Climate Collaborative
Our Coast, Our Future 3.0
San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission (BCDC) Adapting to Rising Tides (ART) Program, Metropolitan Transportation Commission, State Coastal Conservancy, Alameda County Public Works, San Francisco Public Utilities Commission
Adapting to Rising Tides Inundation Maps
Surging Seas
Risk Finder

Climate Central

Sea Level Rise and Coastal Flooding Impacts Viewer
NOAA's Office for
Coastal Management

Coastal Resilience
Ventura

The Nature
Conservancy
The Impacts of Sea Level Rise on California's Coast
Pacific Institute
Exploring California's Climate
The Nature Cal-Adapt

Our Coast, Our Future
Our Coast, Our Future
Our Coast, Our Future 3.0
Point Blue Conservation Science; USGS; USC Sea Grant, San Diego Regional Climate Collaborative
Adapting to Rising Tides Inundation Maps
San Francisco Bay Conservation and Development Commission (BCDC) Adapting to Rising Tides (ART) Program, Metropolitan Transportation Commission, State Coastal Conservancy, Alameda County Public Works, San Francisco Public Utilities Commission
GENERAL
Geographic Scope Geographic extent the tool defines or covers (i.e. national, statewide, county…) Available for the entire contiguous coastal U.S. -- 22 states and Washington, D.C. -- with releases planned for HI and AK in the future. National (with the exception of AK) Expanding and now includes 14 U.S. coastal states (AL, CA, CT, FL, HI, LA, ME, MS, NJ, NY, NC, TX, VA, WA), the Caribbean (Grenada, St. Vincent and the Grenadines, U.S. Virgin Islands), and across Mexico and Central America (Belize, Guatemala, Honduras). Also global and U.S. national web maps together form the Coastal Resilience network. California California North-central CA Coast (Bodega Head to Half Moon Bay) and San Francisco Bay Southern California (Point Conception to U.S. Mexico Border). Currently creating model for Central Coast (Half Moon Bay to Point Conception) using 3.0 methodologies All 9 counties surrounding San Francisco Bay
Link The URL or link where the tool can be accessed riskfinder.climatecentral.org/ coast.noaa.gov/digitalcoast/tools/slr, coast.noaa.gov/slrdata/ maps.coastalresilience.org http://pacinst.org/publication/the-impacts-of-sea-level-rise-on-the-california-coast/ http://cal-adapt.org/sealevel/ http://pointblue.org/ocof http://ourcoastourfuture.org http://adaptingtorisingtides.org
Description Brief 2-3 sentence description of the purpose of the tool. Searchable web tool providing 1) maps users can customize, embed, & download; 2) downloads: spreadsheets, slideshow-ready tables & graphs, & fact sheets; 3) individual community analyses; 4) area comparisons; 5) local sea level & flood risk projections. 100+ demographic, economic & infrastructure variables analyzed for 1000s of communities from zip code to statewide levels. Tool allows users to visualize community-level impacts from coastal flooding or sea level rise and provides easy access to inundation and elevation data via NOAA's Digital Coast. An online mapping tool customized for local and state decision makers showing potential impacts from sea level rise and coastal hazards designed to help communities develop and implement solutions that incorporate ecosystem-based adaptation approaches Provides access to sea-level rise scenarios generated by the Pacific Institute, ESA PWA and the U.S. Geological Survey as part of the CA Energy Commission's Public Interest Energy Research Program (PIER). The tool shows the threat of coastal erosion and inundation due to flooding over three depths based on a 100 year flood scenario. Currently (spring 2016) provides access to two different sea-level rise flooding models. The first is based on the CoSMoS model developed by USGS to represent sea level rise and storm events, accounting for physical structures, wave dynamics, coastal erosion, and other hydrodynamical factors. These data are available for the Bay Area and outer coast from Bodega Head to just south of Pillar Point Harbor in Half Moon Bay. The second ("bathtub") model represents the open coast as well as Bay Area based on scenarios generated by the Pacific Institute, ESA PWA and the U.S. Geological Survey as part of the Energy Commission's Public Interest Energy Research Program (PIER). ... The tool shows the threat of inundation due to flooding over three depths based on a 100 year flood scenario. NOTE: Cal-Adapt is currently (summer 2016) being migrated to "Cal-Adapt 2.0", which is based on an Applications Programming Interface (API) that enables development of third-party tools. Cal-Adapt 2.0 will also display (summer/fall 2016) 1- results from high-resolution hydrodynamic modeling of extreme storm events + various increments of sea level rise (up to 1.4 m) for the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta, Bay Area, and open coast; 2- results from an ongoing research project funded by the Energy Commission to produce a probabilistic interpretation of the wide range of plausible sea level rise for California. http://beta.cal-adapt.org/ A collaborative, user-driven project focused on providing San Francisco Bay Area coastal resource and land use managers and planners locally relevant, online maps and tools to help understand, visualize, and anticipate vulnerabilities to sea level rise and storms. A visualization tool that allows user to view USGS CoSMoS projections for So Cal. Users are able to explore 10 SLR (0 - 2 m and 5 m) and 4 storm (daily conditions, annual, 20 year and 100 year return) flood hazard projections, as well as shoreline change (sandy beach and cliff retreat) projections. The sea level rise and extreme tide inundation maps use a "One Map=Many Futures" or the total water level approach. The maps show the inland areas that are at risk of inundation, and the companion products -- the shoreline delineation, shoreline type, and overtopping potential maps -- identify the pathways of inundation from the Bay. Together, the products support the development of both near-term and long-term adaptation strategies.
Target Audience The assumed users of the tool (e.g. planners, coastal managers, public) Decision makers, planners, coastal managers, emergency managers, federal and state agencies, journalists and the general public Decision makers, planners, coastal managers, floodplain managers, emergency managers, coastal scientists and engineers, general public Decision makers, planners, coastal managers, emergency managers, coastal scientists and engineers Public, community planners, businesses Public, community planners, businesses, local governments, scientists seeking to coordinate scenarios with those used for California's Fourth Climate Change Assessment Decision makers, planners, coastal managers, floodplain managers, emergency managers, coastal scientists and engineers, general public Including but not limited to: Land Use Planners, Coastal Resource Managers, Restoration Managers, Hazard Mitigation Planners, Floodplain Managers, Emergency Managers, Stormwater Managers, Municipal Engineers, Municipal Leaders, Zoning and Permitting Officials, Public Works Officials, and Conservation Organizations Decision makers, planners, coastal managers, floodplain managers, emergency managers, coastal scientists and engineers, private entities, nonprofits, general public
Skill Level Low (no formal training other than basic computer skills); Medium (need moderate amount of knowledge about coastal management or processes to interpret results); High (need high level of knowledge to interpret information). Low Low to Medium Low-Medium Low Low Low Low Medium
Main Tool Outputs Qualitatively different tool functions or modules that a user can take from the tool. For example, a map might be the primary output, however, the tool may also allow the user to comparisons, scenarios or generate reports. Maps, community analyses, wide area analysis comparisons, projections, downloads & reports Maps, sea level rise scenarios, photo simulations, flood frequency graphs Maps (on-screen and pdf), Summary reports (on-screen), Bookmark links, Downloadable spatial data Maps Maps, reports of inundation threat by county Maps (on screen;, summary reports (on screen and pdf); downloadable data; SLR projection comparison by both amount and year Maps (on screen), summary reports (on screen and pdf); downloadable data; SLR projection comparison by both amount and year; shoreline change projections (for cliffs and sandy beach) Maps and accompanying sea level rise and extreme tide matrixes for each county (indicating the SLR and extreme tide combinations represented by the 10 levels of inundation)
Year Released Year the most current version of the tool was released. Rolling release starting Fall 2013 2011 Gulf of Mexico / 2012 US West and Mid-Atlantic Coasts / 2013 US NW, SW and Pacific Islands / 2014 Puerto Rico, USVI, NE / 2015 Louisianna 2013 2009 May 2014 ("bathtub" model); June 2015 (COSMoS model). Forthcoming in 2016: probabilistic sea level rise projections, Radke et al's modeling of Delta, Bay, and open coast inundation 2013 Half Moon Bay to Bodega Head, 2014 SF Bay Feb 2017 2016-2017
Date Column Last Updated July 2016 April 2017 October 2014 May 2014 April 2016 May 2014 September 2017 March 2018
Top Three Strengths As succinctly as possible, list the top three strengths that make this tool unique. 1) Comprehensive tool providing exposure analysis, comparisons, and projections, as well as an interactive map. 2) Analyses cover ~100 variables, and conducted for 1000's of individual areas (zips, cities, counties, states, planning and legislative districts at all levels). 3) Local projections combine sea level rise and storm surge to give integrated risk estimates by decade. 1) Easy to use via Web browser, with GIS analysis results and map services available; 2) Uses consistent data sets and analysis for coastal areas nation-wide; 3) Includes photos and allows users to customize local scenarios and visualize impacts of sea level rise at known locations. 1) DESIGN: The tool has a modular, plugin architecture: Coastal Resilience “apps” can be developed by anyone and plugged into the web-based mapping platform. This allows developers to design a specific application to highlight a coastal management issue, respond to a disaster for post-storm decision making, or emphasize nature-based alternatives; 2) PERFORMANCE: Coastal Resilience 2.0 runs faster; ... operates on tablets; works nationally and globally; is open source, and it’s easy to share results and data; 3) PARTNERSHIPS: Developed among core partners including The Nature Conservancy, University of Southern Mississippi, The Natural Capital Project, NOAA Coastal Services Center, and the Association of State Floodplain Managers 1) First comprehensive analysis of the impacts of sea level rise across the state of California. 2) Considered impacts from several depths of inundation, coastal storms and erosion. 3) Used FEMA's HAZUS model to estimate level of economic risk from inundation 1- Continually updated. 2- Forthcoming enhancements will include detailed representation of potential impacts (with regard to levee overtopping) of sea level rise plus extreme storm events in the Sacramento-San Joaquin Delta as well as the Bay area and open coast, based on three-dimensional hydrodynamic modeling. 3- Forthcoming enhancements will include probabilistic sea level rise projections to help decision-makers contend with a wide range of plausible SLR values for California. 1) The model underlying the tool, CoSMoS, applies a deterministic modeling framework to cover large geographic scales but with fine local resolution. The system incorporates atmospheric forcing (i.e., wind and pressure fields) from Global Climate Models and accounts for all the relevant physical processes that will contribute to the vulnerability of the coast now and in the future (e.g., SLR, tide, waves, surge, fluvial discharge, storm variability) and the resulting coastal hazards. ... 2) One of the primary objectives of this project is to understand regional coastal flood planning information needs and develop our tools based on those needs. Three scoping meetings with over 140 planners, managers, and scientists were held. In addition, a subset of these attendees took part in an Outer Coast Focus Group to help beta test the North-central coast flood map and a San Francisco Bay Advisory Committee currently advises on the development of the Bay flood map. 3) Three areas of technical assistance is provided: 1. Targeted Trainings to agency/org staff on how to utilize the OCOF decision support tools and apply them to relevant on the ground projects; 2. Integration Support for organizations that want to bring OCOF’s SLR scenarios into their own GIS environment or decision support tool; and 3. Technical Assistance Engagement for organizations that want to use OCOF in a planning process and need assistance with scenario planning, tool modification or application, etc. 1) Flooding based on dynamic water levels, including both sea level rise and storms effects. The underlying model, CoSMoS, applies a deterministic modeling framework to cover large geographic scales but with fine local resolution. The system incorporates atmospheric forcing (i.e., wind and pressure fields) from Global Climate Models and accounts for all the relevant physical processes that will contribute to the vulnerability of the coast now and in the future (e.g., SLR, tide, waves, storm surge, fluvial discharge, storm variability) and the resulting coastal hazards; ... 2) Evolved digital elevation model based on shoreline change for both sandy beach and cliffs is included to model future flood projections; 3) Model and viewer developed to meet state and federal planning requirements with outreach professionals available to help coastal communities utilize information contained within 1) Based on locally-vetted high resolution topographic data resolved to a 1 meter Digital Elevation Model (DEM) and locally-relevent Bay water levels leveraged from FEMA's recent SF Bay study; 2) Applies the total water level approach so that each map reflects many possible future combinations of sea level rise and extreme water levels; 3) Includes shoreline mapping and analysis products that are critical to understanding the location of shoreline overtopping that could lead to inland flooding.
Top Three Limitations As succinctly as possible, list the top three weaknesses or limitations that coastal planners or managers might encounter using this tool. 1) Map should not be used for site-specific decisions (supplement with direct field measurements of elevation), as wider-area analyses are more robust than point-by-point mapping; 2) Levee data are incomplete, and maps/analyses incorporating levees assume condition good and heights infinite; 3) No physical modeling of storm surge or waves on top of sea level rise. 1) Inundation scenarios do not include coastal storm surge, riverine flooding, erosion or other coastal processes; 2) Appropriate for use as a screening-level or planning tool allowing zoom in scale of approximately 1:18,055, but provides map services and data download for more in depth analysis. 3.) Includes fully enclosed federal levees as mapped by the USACE National Levee Database. Partially enclosed, regional, or local levees have been added in certain locations. 1) ONLINE-ONLY: No ability to access the tools with limited or lack of connectivity; 2) USER-FRIENDLINESS: Not catered to general public, so training is requirement to engage stakeholders so they can fully utilize the tool and understand the data and analyses; 3) COMMUNICATIONS: With so many tools now available on the web, it is hard to decipher the niche and therefore use of this tool relative to others that address similar issues 1) Elevation dataset is inconsistent in terms of resolution and vertical accuracy, 2) Shoreline location is inexact and probably subjective, 3) Flooding is classified by depth only and does not take into account the flow pathway (i.e. are low lying areas hydrologically connected) Same as Pacific Institute and CoSMoS (original Cal-Adapt site); under development (Cal-Adapt 2.0). 1) No side by side comparisons of scenarios or overlays of different scenarios are provided except in the "Detailed View" which requires more technical expertise (overlays are possible there) ; 2) Doesn't currently model projections of shoreline change specific to SLR and storm scenarios; 3) Labels or tags are not currently provided to help users delineate areas of interest, infrastructure, etc. and actual parcels can't be delineated. 1) No side by side comparisons of scenarios or overlays of different scenarios are provided except in the "Detailed View" which requires more technical expertise (overlays are possible there) ; 2) Labels or tags are not currently provided to help users delineate areas of interest, infrastructure, etc. and actual parcels can't be delineated 1) Does not reflect the impact sea level rise will have on riverine flood risk; 2) Does not account for shoreline erosion or change, or for locally-driven wind waves that could increase shoreline overtopping; 3) Does not reflect the potential for flooding due to stormwater infrastructure system back ups or for areas that are flooded to drain through stormwater infrastructure.
Point of Contact Please give a key contact for questions about the tool and its future development. Name and email address. Dan Rizza: drizza@climatecentral.org John Rozum: john.rozum@noaa.gov Zach Ferdana: zferdana@tnc.org Susan Wilhelm: susan.wilhelm@energy.ca.gov,
or Nancy Thomas: nethomas@berkeley.edu
Juliette Finzi Hart: jfinzihart@usgs.gov Patrick Barnard: pbarnard@usgs.gov or Juliette Hart: jfinzihart@usgs.gov Eliza Berry: liza.berry@bcdc.ca.gov eliza.berry@bcdc.ca.gov; Stefanie Hom: shom@mtc.ca.gov
SLR AND FLOOD SCENARIOS
EXPOSURE ANALYSIS
SHORELINE PROCESSES
TECHNICAL SPECIFICATIONS
OTHER